As I warned you a few weeks ago, we have been traveling. Upon return, a few days ago, I had no idea where I would begin to write about our experiences. And then, sadly, I woke to the news of Malaysian Airlines passenger plane that had been shot down over Ukraine. My thoughts brought into focus several threads of our travel experiences that I wanted to share with you.
All during our travels from Hungary to Croatia, Serbia, Romania, Bulgaria and finally to Turkey, we saw signs of war. Not only scars of distant wars, but the still healing wounds of recent battles; bombed out buildings, memorials to brave patriots, graves of entire families. It was sobering, as well as educational. Local guides in each of these places tried their best to tell an accurate version of their country’s story. We tried to make sense of it. But the complexity is mind boggling.
At the end of the tour we took a side trip three hundred kilometres west of Istanbul, to Gallipoli. Over 40,000 lives were lost there in WWI. Next year is the 100th anniversary of that battle. Strangely, it was one of the things that galvanised Australia into the country of today. The events there have not been glorified, but have been lovingly and respectfully acknowledged by the Turks as well as the invading forces. In some places the trenches between the Turks and the Aussie Diggers and New Zealand troops were only 30 feet apart. Some of those trenches still remain.
When we first arrived at the viewing point just before Anzac Cove, the bus stopped and we got off. This was the mistaken landing, the point the troops were sent to, incorrectly. The beauty of the coastline belied the horrors that happened there. As my feet touched the ground it was as if the pressure sent fluid straight to my eyes, welling to the brims. What I can only describe as the presence of many souls, surrounded me and I wept for my adopted land and all those who perished on that inhospitable and impossible terrain.
A couple of years ago we also visited Russia. We were fortunate to have a guest speaker on the cruise. She was a professor at a Russian University and through her wonderful talks she passionately expressed, wars are not a direct result of the people’s desires, but the so-called leaders, often not even elected by the people. That insight was shared again and again on our recent trip. When pushed to desperation, the people will rise up against the politicians/leaders/insurgents. But based on what we have seen, and the people we have spoken to, if the general population had a viable choice, there would be no wars.
On our return flight, I found an old classic movie I had never seen before—The Grapes of Wrath (1940). I’m not a particular fan of old movies but something about the timing and my state of mind caused me to select it. It was good. For those uninitiated, it is a story of the terrible ‘dust bowl’ days (1930’s) in the USA and how people were driven from their land and forced West to look for work and begin life again. Thematically, it reminded me of some of the countries we had just seen; people starting again, through no choice of their own, and with nothing.
The final lines in the movie stayed with me, an echo of many of the voices we have heard all over the world:
Ma Joad (matriarch of the story, talking to her husband, Pa):
Rich fellas come up an’ they die, an’ their kids ain’t no good an’ they die out. But we keep a’comin’. We’re the people that live. They can’t wipe us out; they can’t lick us. We’ll go on forever, Pa, ’cause we’re the people’.
In the coming weeks when we are listening to the various versions of the Malaysian Airline tragedy, let us all remember to keep cool heads and encourage our leaders to keep cool heads. Those who do these things are the minority, not ‘the people’. There are myriad options, other than war and bombs. Whoever shot that missile and killed 298 people, were desperate rebels, which in no way justifies their actions, and they should be accountable. But let us remember, those who pick up the pieces and rebuild and go on forever, are the people. It is just so, everywhere.
Evocative images! I love the eerie (and appropriate) feel of the Croatian grave memorial – the echoes of the crosses says it all.
LikeLike
Thank you so much. The whole trip had undertones of sadness for the senseless death that has taken place, and yet, I’m very glad we did it.
LikeLike
I was deeply moved by this piece of writing. Thankyou Ardy, for bringing together these thoughts of war, travel and people in such a time.
LikeLike
Thank you Francesca. It is a struggle to make sense of the sad things in this world, and mostly we can’t.
LikeLike
Beautifully said Ardys.
xxx Massive Hugs xxx
LikeLike
Thank you David.
LikeLike
Dear Ardys, You wrote this with all your rationality, and sentiments, too! So important for me, at these tragic times, to read your post, and to see the photos! Thanks so much for having written this! The parallel with The Grapes of Wrath is so precise! You ending the piece with ‘ But let us remember, those who pick up the pieces and rebuild and go on forever, are the people. It is just so, everywhere’ gives us hope. That’s what we need now. Thanks so much, Ardys! Take care.
PS: I am sending a link to your post to my close friends.
LikeLike
Thank you Fabio. The more I travel the more I realise people are people, the world over.
LikeLike
Ardys, we have the same feelings. We came from Brazil, and then went to live in Canada, Louisiana, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Florida, and now in California. We have a son living in New Zealand. By sharing all our experiences, we can also conclude that people are the same, no matter the place. Thanks so much for your beautiful testimony! Take care!
LikeLike
Thoughtful, eloquent, elegant. Love this piece Ardys. Thankyou.
LikeLike
Thank you Leanda.
LikeLike
Your essay truly touched me today, Ardys, with its somber message and quiet reflections. I’m not sure how many folks would see the worth of spending vacation time to remember and memorialize others and the efforts they gave toward our freedoms. I have such a deep respect for you in doing so. In the end, I think after investing that time, one ends up realizing what a gift it really was–to see these war torn places and step upon the ground that still somehow murmurs with the voices of those who fought there. It’s chilling and beautiful and so worthy.
Thank you for sharing with us your travels and most importantly your thoughts. Eloquent as always, heartfelt as ever.
xxo
LikeLike
There were some lighter moments on our trip, but the overarching theme for me was to be SO grateful for where I live now, and also the country in which I was born. To have choices is truly a blessing, one many people on this earth don’t have. Thank you Shelley, your comments are always so appreciated.
LikeLike
Wonderful and wise words Adys. Thank you.
LikeLike
Thank you Suz.
LikeLike
I read this thoughtful touching post very early on Sunday morning with the G.O. still asleep beside me, and thought, not for the first time, how fortunate are we in our uneventual lives. Taking time to think about it, and MH17 and the memorials other wars, there are so many questions and no answers that will change anything retrospectively. More lost people, devastated left-behind loved ones, and residents of the surrounding villages shocked & saddened but compassionate & grieving also. There is comfort in that we will of course go on until our time comes as well, and in this we are all equal. But there is powerless frustration at this senseless loss, and inevitably other future loss just as there has been past, at the hands of people who are different but the same.
LikeLike
Oh, yes, how fortunate we are for our uneventful lives! I feel very privileged to have written something to illicit such a beautiful response. You always write lovely, thoughtful responses, but especially so this time. Thank you.
LikeLike
Pingback: I wish us peace | Anne Lawson
Pingback: We’re the People – Istanbul | ardysez
Pingback: We’re the People – Budapest | ardysez
Pingback: We’re the People – Alice Springs | ardysez