Tags
african americans, Books, humanity, Isabel Wilkerson, krista tippett, migrants, migration, podcast, the great migration, the warmth of other suns
Our country is like an old house, and old houses need fixing, and more fixing –Isabel Wilkerson (from podcast ‘On Being’ with Krista Tippett*)
As you will recall, I usually post a list of my favourite books at the end of each year. This one just couldn’t wait. Because we can’t wait. Our world needs every day possible to do better. The Warmth of Other Suns by Pulitzer Prize winning writer, Isabel Wilkerson is the best work of non-fiction I have ever read. The story she tells is one of a country within a country and how its people struggled, and still struggle, to be recognised as equal. But in this day of mass migrations it is also a universal story. Isabel researched this book for 10 years and then spent 5 years writing it. The quality and care of her efforts are evident. The historic fabric of one of America’s most underreported stories is woven from carefully transcribed anecdotal telling, research and statistics so deftly threaded throughout, it reads like a novel. All 622 pages of it.
The Warmth of Other Suns is one of those books I did not want to end, but not because it paints a pretty picture of life in the US between 1915 and 1975. I didn’t want it to end because it was a fascinating revelation—a third of which happened during the first 20 years of my life. If you think you know this story, you probably don’t. I am very sorry to say, I was completely oblivious to what is now called The Great Migration. Since it was so underreported, my ignorance is partially understandable. The Great Migration is the epic story of how over six million black people living in the south of the United States, moved north and west during a period of about 60 years, trying to escape the extreme segregation of the south. ‘Jim Crow‘, as the segregationist regime was called, disallowed colored people to walk on the sidewalk alongside white people, to sit in the same seats on public transport, to buy the same real estate, indeed any real estate at all…and worse.
Growing up in rural southern Ohio is also partly why the movement was not in my consciousness. Ohio was geographically part of the North. It boasted a very effective ‘underground railroad’ which spirited runaway slaves to safety, but later on would deny migrating southern blacks the same opportunities migrants from Europe enjoyed. I may have missed the movement, but I was not oblivious to the undercurrent of prejudice that still existed when I was growing up. You may pose the question in your mind, as I did, but weren’t the blacks treated equally after their emancipation at the end of the Civil War in 1865? Not only was this not the case, but the situation worsened for most so-called emancipated ‘colored people’ as they were called in those days. Even after the Civil Rights Act of 1964, many states took another ten years to invoke a version of equality. The truth of this will vary, depending upon who you speak to, much as the extermination of Jews has at times been a point of contention for holocaust deniers. This book has such depth, there can be no doubt of the terrible injustice done to people who had purposely, and gainfully, been introduced to the US, in some cases by tearing them away from their families in Africa, and bringing them to enslavement.
But it is even more than that.
Migrating is never just about migration—it is about freedom —Isabel Wilkerson
Isabel Wilkerson tells the story of speaking at a book signing and looking up to see a little old Greek lady with an armload of copies of her book for her to sign. The Greek lady said “You have told MY story too.” She wanted to share the book with her family. This was the associative experience Wilkerson wanted to convey with her book. As a migrant to Australia, and the grandchild of a migrant, I read the book with great interest. The Great Migration was also about moving from the ‘Old Country’ in the south, to the ‘New World’ in the north for the migrants. It overlapped the huge influx of migrants from Europe, some of which were my family, and so it was the plight many people faced. But the colored people were at the bottom of the pile, even though they had been in the country for twelve generations previously.
If all history books were written as well as this one I would have been a better history student. This work has been a real awakening with respect to government policy regarding migrants, as well as the recalcitrant behaviour of the general population whose unconscious collusion continues today. When we know better we can do better, but it is still a choice.
A month ago when I began reading, I had no idea I would finish it on Martin Luther King Day (USA), in the same week as the first African American President of the USA would finish his second term in office. With Australia Day coming in a week, I can’t help but think of all the challenges both of my countries have before them. We have so much experience from which to draw it is a wonder we still falter when encountering someone who is different from us. And yet we do. I hope many will read this book and find knowledge and compassion, and perhaps even part of their own story within its pages.
Do the best you can, then when you know better, do better. –Maya Angelou
*If you have 51 minutes, listen to the podcast linked in the opening quotation, via your computer.
From where I sit, literally, I can relate to the ‘old house’ metaphor. Like countries, they can be fixed, fixed… but the inherited history, scars and evidence of others’ workmanship or lack thereof remain. Despite, or because of this, for it to prosper we must treat our house/country the best we can as caretakers for the future.
Australia Day has been on my mind. The G.O. & I celebrate it modestly, privately as proud Australians but we’re aware of the negatives. It’s bittersweet, considering the realities of our county’s history.
The podcast and The Warmth of Other Suns interest me. When we were travelling I picked up a book from a laundry swap shelf that I had no idea would so much impact my understanding… The Immortal Life of Henriettea Lacks by Rebecca Skloot. There is a cross over of era and subject matter.
Finally the real history of our countries is emerging but true understanding and empathy I think is slower. It is Past but the tangible effects remain. Without going into too much detail… rant… here, our travels were an eyeopener, and in many cases, places we saw circumstances that were just Wrong. Because I think there is still no collective understanding that there is no We, no Them, no They… just Us and We need to make actions for the Better now and for the future. Regardless of Who or Type, disadvantage and marginalisation isn’t Someone Else’s problem, it belongs to every one of us whether we agree or not, it speaks of our Society… How can we who have quality of life enjoy it with good conscience while others cannot.
LikeLiked by 3 people
What a great comment, Dale. I believe the book by ‘Skoots’ is referred to in the podcast interview as it came out in the same year as Wilkerson’s book, 2010. As the saying goes ‘travel is the antidote to prejudice’–by Mark Twain, I believe. I have already downloaded the ‘Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks’. Thank you for mentioning it. I think one of the things I valued most in Wilkerson’s book is the way our government and our behaviours dictate our future. It is so clear the way she carefully documents everything. Woe be us who desire to continue living unconsciously.
LikeLike
Podcast was excellent, was glad I’d read ‘Skoots’ book as frame of reference.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A profound comment Dale, especially as Australia Day looms which is not a day of celebration for our indigenous people. Travelling around Australia definitely widens our eyes to the on going wrongs in our own country, the situation in Alice Springs being particularly confronting, as well as in other settlements and communities in the Northern territory. A good history is an eye opener too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
My knowledge of modern American history is sparse I confess, although I’m old enough to remember the race riots of 70s. I’ll add this title to my reading list. I really enjoy sociological history.
The Fatal Shore by the late great Robert Hughes is my definitive Australia’s history read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for the tip, Sandra, I will add that to my list. Wilkerson’s book really does read like a novel for the most part. Hope you are holding up in the heat…I’m barely functioning.
LikeLike
As you know, I get easily overwhelmed and frustrated – I feel and see so much pain and hurt in the world. After reading your post last night, FD and I happened to watch an old episode from, “Who Do You Think You Are” (On The Learning Channel – TLC) where Reba McEntire, a country music vocalist from Oklahoma, went back on her mother’s side of the family to discover four generations back grandfather was the owner of slaves, and the six generation back grandfather who came to America at the age of nine as an indentured slave. It’s quite one thing to investigate American history from books, but to understand from a personal background – to understand how our lives were affected by history and by our own ancestors – it’s certainly humbling.
I have struggled greatly with the recent anger and uprising in America. Riots, police killings, corrupt media, slandering and lying… it’s certainly not “knowing better and doing better”. I grew up in the 60’s and 70’s, and I too was a Northerner and perhaps was more sheltered from what was really going on in our country. But I do not ever remember seeing the ugliness and hate that I am seeing now. I feel so overwhelmed that I simply cannot expose myself to much media.So, I am doing a lot of reading these days (normally, my life here does not allow much reading!) and I look forward to reading this book. Thank you for suggesting it, Ardys.
LikeLiked by 1 person
If you have the time, listen to the podcast link here and you will get a good idea of what the book is about and the voice it has. It is not angry and pointing fingers it is telling the story of how things were. I feel like it was a critical puzzle piece that fell into place in terms of my understanding so many things about when I was growing up and their connection to things that are happening now. I can appreciate how overwhelming the media must be for you. I have to limit my exposure too. I saw that episode of “Who Do You Think You Are” with Reba and it was powerful. Take Care Lori.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ardys, what a wonderful post, and wonderful comments… sounds like a wonderful book that brings all the facts together… I read Uncle Tom’s Cabin when I was seven, and have been immersed in the plight of blacks ever since… especially the Jim Crowe laws.. Ken Burns series on jazz tells the story too, including Billie Holiday’s shocking song ‘ Bitter Fruit,’
I’ve always thought that ‘Gone With the Wind’, written from a white southern viewpoint, was one of the most dangerous books to ever become a best seller. It lulled so many people into complacence about the ‘romantic South’.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Boy, you are right about ‘Gone With the Wind’ being a romanticised version of life in the south. Nothing wrong with artistic license, as long as people realise it isn’t a true depiction. Just heard an interview this morning encouraging people to ‘think’ more when they interact with social media. Now there’s a radical idea! The most valuable insight from reading ‘The Warmth of Other Suns’ is how it connects to what is happening in the US at the moment. Thank you for reading and commenting Valerie, much appreciated.
LikeLike
This sounds like a very good history to put on the reading list for 2017 and shall listen to the podcast as well as a ‘taster’. Another history/sociology of note that might interest you is Don Watson’s American Journeys.
LikeLike
Thank you Francesca, I’ll add that to the list that grows faster than I can read! The podcast is actually how I learned of the book, so it is a very good taster indeed, and I wasn’t disappointed.
LikeLiked by 1 person